Skip to content
Insights

Member Expectations vs. Loyalty Investment: Spending More May Not Drive Outcomes

As loyalty budgets rise, are organizations investing in the rewards and experiences their members value and can access?

Stacey Sutherland · 20 November 2026

Shoppers walking in different directions through a retail concourse, with motion-blurred figures and a blue-to-teal overlay.

Member satisfaction alone can't tell loyalty leaders where their next investment should go. Members might be satisfied with the organizations they belong to, yet still expect more from their loyalty programs, particularly the rewards and benefits they receive.

With more budget for loyalty, rewards and engagement, program leaders have more choices about where to invest, expecting those investments to encourage members to engage more, spend more, prevent churn and remain loyal to their brands.

While that’s a reasonable expectation, not every loyalty program investment improves what members receive. A technology upgrade can improve operations without making rewards more valuable or effective, and additional benefits can have limited impact if members can't access them or don’t find them relevant or useful.

That distinction should weigh heavily when deciding where to invest more. But how do program leaders know which of them will improve a member’s experience enough to influence engagement, spending and retention?

Our recent surveys of 250 loyalty and membership benefits decision-makers and over 2,000 consumers in the United States examine those investment decisions from two perspectives, comparing where organizations plan to direct investment with what members say would make their loyalty programs more valuable. The findings in Beyond Enrollment: The Wins, Losses and Opportunities in Loyalty show strong alignment, especially between investment priorities and member expectations around rewards and redemption but also reveal where members still struggle to access the benefits they value most.

What higher loyalty budgets are expected to deliver

The planned increases in loyalty program budgets make those decisions more consequential. Eighty-six percent of the loyalty program professionals surveyed expect their budgets for loyalty, travel benefits and related engagement technology to increase over the next 12 to 24 months. Their top priorities are increasing active member engagement, cited by 22%, and improving rewards relevance and value perception, cited by 21%.

While those priorities tell us what leaders want to achieve, they don’t reveal which investments are most likely to deliver those results.

But while budgets measure intent, members will respond to what they can see and use, even if not immediately. Additional spending can support those goals when it gives members stronger reasons to participate, but increased investment doesn't fix mismatched rewards or guarantee better program performance. Leaders should judge each new dollar allocation by its effect on engagement, redemption, retention, and renewal rather than counting a budget increase as progress on its own. That connection between member behavior and business value is central to the economics of loyalty.

Members want more than one kind of value

Consumers react differently to reward types and program features for many reasons, so a more considered approach to rewards investment is necessary.

Everyday rewards give members a reason to keep using a program, while larger, more aspirational rewards give them something worth earning toward. Our research reflects both motivations, with 40% of consumers saying more valuable everyday rewards would increase their engagement and 32% pointing to bigger, more exciting rewards. Relevance, ease of redemption and the digital experience also influence whether members see enough value in those rewards to participate more often.

A favorable assessment of a loyalty program doesn't necessarily extend to its rewards. Almost three-quarters of consumers say their program consistently exceeds expectations or generally meets them. Yet, a quarter find the rewards insufficiently valuable, and nearly as many say they're difficult to earn or redeem, or irrelevant to their needs. Another 19% believe their program could provide considerably more value. And that distinction is easy to overlook when overall satisfaction becomes the measure of a program's success.

Even programs members rate positively have room to improve, but the next investment depends on what members say needs improving. A program lacking relevant or valuable rewards faces a different challenge from one whose members value the benefits but struggle to earn or redeem them. Those distinctions should inform whether additional budget goes toward expanding the rewards portfolio, improving the redemption experience or a combination of the two.

Where program investment and member priorities meet

At first glance, organizations appear to be directing investment toward many of the improvements consumers want, with 55% most likely to increase spending on loyalty and rewards program capabilities, followed by artificial intelligence (49%), travel benefits and booking experiences (41%) and member engagement and retention tools (41%). Planned upgrades are similarly concentrated around rewards and redemption experiences, loyalty platform technology and travel booking and fulfillment.

The priorities are broadly consistent, but these investment categories tell us more about the capabilities organizations intend to improve rather than the additional value members will receive.

What those investments must accomplish varies by sector, from engagement and differentiation in retail to retention and lifetime value in insurance, renewal in membership and affinity programs, participation and member satisfaction in health and wellness, and spend and redemption in financial services.

Allocating budget to the right priorities doesn’t necessarily mean members will notice the result. Visibility and availability are the missing ingredients; a capability members never notice adds cost without driving engagement or ROI. Travel rewards are the clearest example of misalignment between importance, demand and availability across most programs, with many members still unable to find them.

Making impactful rewards more visible… and available

Travel is already an established priority for loyalty leaders. In our survey, 84% of loyalty program professionals said it was extremely or very important for their organization's member benefits, rewards or engagement strategy to include travel-related experiences.

Consumers also recognize its value: 66% agreed that a membership or loyalty program offering travel and vacation benefits would be more valuable than one that offers only discounts, points or cash rewards. Travel can serve as a higher-value, aspirational reward alongside everyday rewards, combining two types of value that our research found can encourage greater engagement. But that potential depends on whether members can find and use the travel benefits they value in the first place.

Yet many members still can't access the travel benefits that organizations consider strategically important. Across the eight categories we tested, between 35% and 45% of consumers say their programs don't offer them. Thirty-five percent say they can't redeem points or rewards for travel at all.

The gaps widen for car rental (38%), flight benefits and travel insurance (40% each) and cruise vacations (45%). For loyalty and membership leaders, that uneven access severely limits travel's role in driving member engagement and program performance, regardless of how much they prioritize travel in their broader loyalty strategies.

More importantly, these benefits can significantly influence the outcomes organizations expect from their loyalty investments. In our study, roughly one in four consumers said valuable travel and vacation benefits would make them more likely to explore additional products or services, recommend the organization, renew, engage more often or spend more.

Many organizations already prioritize travel. But until that priority translates into benefits members can readily access and use, its potential to drive engagement, spending and retention will remain limited.

Start strong with member value, end stronger with business outcomes

The strongest investment decisions start by identifying which rewards and experiences carry enough value to change member behavior, then determining which improvements can deliver that value and support the program's commercial objectives, whether that’s improving engagement, participation, retention, spend, customer lifetime value and program ROI.

That means distinguishing between the need for more valuable rewards, better access to existing benefits and the technology required to deliver them. Each calls for a different investment decision, even when the intended outcomes are the same.

A growing budget only proves its worth when it gives members more reasons to return, redeem, renew and spend. Travel offers a compelling, proven opportunity to put that principle to work. Consumers clearly see value in travel rewards, yet many programs don't let them access any travel benefits, or if they do, they’re often generic. Investment that addresses these constraints serves a strong commercial purpose, rather than simply adding capabilities without improving what members receive.

Discover what today’s members expect, where programs could deliver more value, and how to get more from your loyalty program investment.

Download Beyond Enrollment here.

Frequently asked questions

What are loyalty leaders prioritizing as budgets increase?

In arrivia’s research, 86% of loyalty professionals expected budgets for loyalty, travel benefits and related engagement technology to rise over the next 12 to 24 months. Their top priorities were increasing active member engagement (22%) and making rewards more relevant and valuable to members (21%).

Can members be satisfied with a loyalty program and still want better rewards?

Yes. Nearly three-quarters of surveyed consumers said their programs generally meet or consistently exceed expectations, yet one in four found the rewards insufficiently valuable. Asking members about reward relevance and ease of redemption can reveal gaps that overall satisfaction scores miss.

Why should loyalty programs consider investing in travel rewards?

Two-thirds of surveyed consumers (66%) said a program with travel and vacation benefits would be more valuable than one offering only discounts, points or cash rewards. Yet 35% said they couldn’t redeem points or rewards for travel at all, highlighting an opportunity to make travel benefits easier to find and use.

How can loyalty leaders decide where to invest their next dollar?

Start by identifying what keeps members from using their benefits. If rewards feel irrelevant, improve the selection. If members value the rewards but struggle to use them, focus on visibility, availability or redemption. Then measure the investment against its intended outcome, such as more redemptions, higher spending or stronger renewal rates.