Skip to content
Insights

Building a Competitive Travel Rewards Portfolio Starts With the Right Partners

Choosing partners for your loyalty program means looking beyond inventory to redemption, integration and support as member needs change.

Stacey Sutherland · 20 November 2026

Aerial view of a cruise ship sailing through open water, with swimming pools and sun loungers on deck beneath a blue-to-teal overlay.

Loyalty program members aren’t one-dimensional abstractions; they’re human beings whose budgets and priorities can change considerably over time. A member might spend months accumulating points for a special vacation, then decide they would rather use them to reduce everyday expenses after an unexpected cost arises. Their circumstances have changed and so have what they want (and need) from their program.

For loyalty leaders, keeping rewards relevant as members' circumstances and preferences change is an ongoing challenge. Our 2024 Travel Loyalty Outlook Report found that organizations struggled to offer rewards that members find valuable. Two years later, addressing that challenge remains a priority. In our latest research, 21% of loyalty decision-makers say improving rewards relevance and perceived value is their top loyalty priority over the next 24 months.  

Knowing which rewards members value helps organizations decide what to offer, but delivering those benefits depends on their partners’ inventory and capabilities. Our latest research report, Beyond Enrollment: The Wins, Losses and Opportunities in Loyalty, explores that connection. Partners’ rewards inventory and capabilities also shape which benefits an organization can offer, how it can differentiate its program and how much its own team needs to manage.

Even when organizations identify benefits that would strengthen their programs, existing supplier relationships can limit their ability to introduce or expand them. Supplier relationships therefore affect both the value members receive  and the commercial opportunities a program can pursue.

When travel providers don’t offer the rewards your members want

Travel benefits offer an ideal case study. In our research, 66% of consumers say a program with travel and vacation benefits would be more valuable than one offering only discounts, points or cash. Yet organizations don’t always provide the travel options they believe would appeal to their members.

Cruise provides a clear example of the gap between the benefits organizations want to offer and what their suppliers can provide. Only 41% of decision-makers who consider cruise one of the most valuable travel benefits currently offer it. Supplier limitations are often the culprit: among organizations that do not offer cruise, 28% say the category is unavailable through their existing travel rewards provider.

For these organizations, expanding the rewards portfolio to meet their commercial priorities and members' interests may require looking outside their current supplier relationships.

Nearly 60% of decision-makers already supplement existing relationships with secondary vendors or partners when their current provider can’t meet their needs. Supplementing a provider can preserve what already works while giving the program access to something new. A retailer looking to introduce cruise benefits, for example, could work with a specialist supplier to expand its offering while maintaining its primary travel rewards provider relationship.

However, repeatedly onboarding new suppliers can introduce its own complexity. When each new benefit requires another integration or workaround, organizations need to consider whether their current provider relationships are still supporting their long-term objectives. Our research suggests limited capabilities can be consequential enough to prompt a change: 44% of decision-makers say better capabilities elsewhere would lead them to seriously consider replacing an existing provider.

That doesn’t make replacement the automatic answer, but leaders should weigh the cost and disruption of changing providers against the work required to keep filling gaps and the lost opportunities they create.

Deciding which gaps to address also depends on each program’s priorities. A credit union seeking more competitive redemption options has different requirements from an affinity group looking to encourage renewals. Those differences help organizations decide which benefits to add and what to look for in a partner.

Different loyalty programs have different requirements… and priorities

Consider the credit union. Adding cruise benefits to its portfolio could help it compete with established credit card rewards programs that use travel to attract members but may not offer cruises. But members need a realistic path to redemption: 63% of financial services decision-makers say a favorable earning-to-redemption ratio would make cruise more attractive to customers. If booking feels out of reach, the advantage is limited. The provider also needs to support redemption options that make the benefit attainable for members with different rewards balances.

For retailers, the comparison may be more immediate: can shoppers get a better price elsewhere? Sixty-two percent of retail and membership decision-makers say deep discounts compared with other booking options would make cruise more attractive. A retailer seeking to distinguish its benefits from competitors’ offers needs a supplier that can deliver meaningful savings.

An affinity organization may find that even an attractive price does little to support renewal if members can’t find a trip that fits their plans. Among decision-makers in this sector, 62% identify wide availability and few blackout dates as factors that would make cruise more appealing.

These differences across sectors reinforce the importance of supplier flexibility. With 83% of organizations surveyed already offering travel benefits, programs need to consider what would set their offering apart, not just expand their catalog. The same provider could serve each organization, but it must accommodate their individual priorities and how they want to deliver value to members.

The operational demands of travel rewards: Evaluating partners beyond inventory and pricing

Even when organizations find suppliers with the right inventory and pricing, introducing new travel benefits involves more than adding options for members. Booking technology, redemption processing, payment handling, fulfillment and customer support all need to work within the existing program. If a provider cannot support these requirements, the responsibility may fall to the organization itself.

While 50% of loyalty decision-makers say they handle capability gaps internally when their provider can’t meet their needs, doing so pressures organizations with limited resources and stretches internal teams beyond their expertise.

Take an insurer offering hotel and car rental benefits to provide policyholders with additional value between renewals. The reward may give customers another reason to engage with the company, but what happens when someone needs to modify a reservation or resolve a booking problem? Asking the policy support team to resolve it adds travel-related work outside its insurance expertise. A specialist partner can provide the booking technology and travel support to manage these requests, reducing the work that falls to the insurer.

However, external support must also meet the organization's existing technical, operational and security requirements. Among insurance decision-makers, 57% identify strong integrations and APIs as essential provider capabilities, and the same share select fraud, security and compliance capabilities.

These considerations are especially relevant as organizations plan further investment in their rewards infrastructure.  Our research found that 45% of decision-makers expect to upgrade, replace or introduce travel booking and fulfillment solutions over the next 12–24 months.

For those organizations, evaluating potential partners means looking beyond the inventory on offer to determine how new benefits will be implemented, supported and maintained. A provider should be able to explain which functions it will provide, what integration work is required, and which responsibilities will remain with the organization's internal teams.

Choosing partners that can adapt as your program and member needs change

Expanding a rewards portfolio shouldn't require organizations to rebuild existing systems or continually increase their internal teams' workload. Partner selection needs to account for the benefits a program wants to offer today and the requirements that may emerge as member expectations and commercial priorities change.

Leaders must consider how a provider would introduce new categories, accommodate changes to redemption options and scale support as usage grows. The answers can help organizations determine whether their existing relationships are sufficient, whether specialist suppliers could address specific gaps or whether a different provider would offer greater long-term value.

As member needs change, organizations need the flexibility to respond with benefits that encourage participation, spending and retention. The right partnership should make that response easier, not add barriers to introducing the benefits members want. Ultimately, a competitive travel rewards portfolio depends not just on understanding what members value, but on choosing partners that make it possible to deliver.

Explore how arrivia can help you expand your travel rewards portfolio with the inventory and capabilities to deliver greater value to your members.

Download Beyond Enrollment: The Wins, Losses and Opportunities in Loyalty for the full findings.

Link to article on rewards and engagement value.

Frequently asked questions

What should loyalty programs look for in a travel rewards partner?

Evaluate how the partner will deliver the benefit from booking through post-booking support. Ask how it integrates with your loyalty platform, which redemption options it supports, who handles payments and fulfillment, and who helps members with changes, cancellations or booking issues.

When should a loyalty program add a specialist travel supplier or replace its current provider?

A specialist can fill a specific gap, such as adding cruise, while preserving the parts of the existing program that work well. If gaps keep recurring and each new benefit requires another integration or workaround, compare the cost of switching providers with the ongoing cost and effort of managing multiple suppliers.

Why do travel rewards requirements vary across loyalty programs?

Different programs need travel rewards to do different jobs. A credit union may need redemption options that make cruises attainable at different points balances. A retailer may need discounts that stand out against publicly available prices, while an affinity program may prioritize broad availability and fewer blackout dates so members can find trips that fit their schedules.

Why do some loyalty programs leave cruise out of their travel rewards portfolio?

Existing supplier capabilities can limit what a program offers. In arrivia’s research, only 41% of decision-makers who rated cruise among the most valuable travel benefits currently offered it. Among organizations that did not offer cruise, 28% said it was unavailable through their existing travel rewards provider.