Skip to content
Insights

Rewards Value and Member Participation: Are They Driving Commercial Results?

The rewards members choose influence participation, but engagement tells only part of the story about spending and retention.

Stacey Sutherland · 20 November 2026

A couple smiling as they look at a smartphone beside a train window, with a blue-to-teal overlay

Loyalty programs give members many different reasons to participate, from redeeming everyday rewards and accumulating points toward larger purchases to using benefits between transactions. Higher participation may suggest a loyalty program is performing well, but it doesn't necessarily tell leaders whether that activity is generating additional business value. A retailer may see shoppers return to redeem rewards without knowing whether they're spending more, while an insurer may see policyholders using benefits between renewals without knowing whether that activity contributes to stronger retention.

What constitutes commercially valuable engagement also differs by sector. What shoppers want from a retail rewards program may differ from what members expect from a wellness platform or professional association, and preferences also vary within each program and across age groups. These differences influence which rewards drive participation and which member behaviors most affect program performance.


We examined these differences in our latest research, Beyond Enrollment: The Wins, Losses and Opportunities in Loyalty. Drawing on separate surveys of U.S. consumers and loyalty decision-makers across six sectors, we compared what members value in their rewards with the commercial priorities of the organizations responsible for loyalty and benefits programs.


The relationship between engagement and rewards value is reflected in the priorities of the loyalty leaders we surveyed. Increasing active member engagement (22%) and improving rewards’ relevance and perceived value (21%) are their top two loyalty priorities over the next 24 months.

We explore how those priorities compare with consumer expectations in Member Expectations vs. Loyalty Investment.

A reward that encourages someone to redeem isn't necessarily one that persuades them to spend more or remain a customer. For a retailer whose competitors offer similar discounts, strengthening that proposition may mean looking beyond the next promotion to see whether the reward drives additional spending or discounts on a purchase the customer would have made anyway.

Different rewards, different patterns of participation

The rewards a program offers influence when and how members participate, and consumers’ responses point to two complementary ways programs can support participation: 40% say more valuable everyday rewards would increase their engagement, while 32% want bigger, more exciting rewards to work toward. Everyday savings give customers and members frequent opportunities to benefit from a program.

Larger rewards can give them something to aspire to or offer substantial savings on less frequent purchases. Preferences also extend to how rewards work. Flexibility in earning and redemption also influences how members participate and whether they can use the rewards they've accumulated.

Travel is one example. A retailer might have members redeem discounts regularly while others accumulate points over a year toward a planned trip or book a cruise through an exclusive member offer. Each represents a different participation pattern within the same program. A broader rewards portfolio can accommodate these different preferences, but its commercial value depends on whether the benefits encourage additional spending, repeat engagement or retention.

Across sectors, rewards can encourage engagement at different intervals and through different activities. A longer gap between points redemptions need not signal declining interest if members are still earning toward a goal or using other benefits.

Redemption frequency alone provides an incomplete picture of loyalty program engagement. Loyalty leaders must also understand what members are earning toward, how they use other benefits, and whether that participation supports the program's commercial objectives.

Matching benefits to members’ interests and plans

Members’ interests provide a starting point for deciding where additional choice could help. In health and wellness, 28% of members surveyed say greater personalization and relevance would encourage them to engage more. But identifying an appealing benefit doesn't establish whether members will use it. Timing, availability and redemption requirements can be as influential as the offer itself.

Travel provides a great example. A cruise might be exactly what a member wants, but the available sailing dates may not suit their plans. Among affinity and membership decision-makers, 62% say better date availability would make cruises more attractive to their members. A wider selection also gives members more to navigate. Personalized offers can help them identify relevant options, while understandable earning and redemption requirements make those benefits easier to use.

Organizations’ investment priorities reflect both needs: 54% of health and wellness decision-makers identify customer data and personalization as likely investment areas, while 52% of respondents across sectors identify rewards and redemption experiences among the capabilities they are most likely to upgrade. The commercial value of those improvements depends largely on whether they help members find and use benefits they might otherwise overlook or abandon.

Before expanding a rewards portfolio, leaders need to understand how members are using the benefits already available. Tracking where they abandon the booking or redemption process can help determine whether low usage reflects limited appeal, confusing requirements or difficulty accessing an offer. A reward that members value but struggle to redeem presents a very different problem from one they don't want.

Connecting participation with business results

Addressing those barriers can encourage participation, giving programs more opportunities to influence members’ decisions. But greater participation is only part of the commercial equation. Its value depends on whether it influences spending, retention or other outcomes that justify the investment.

Our buyer research reflects the different ways organizations assess performance. Just over half (51%) track engagement outcomes such as repeat usage, redemption, retention and satisfaction, while 40% measure commercial outcomes including revenue, bookings and member spending. These measures are closely related, but participation figures alone cannot establish a rewards program's financial contribution.

Consider the insurance industry. Thirty-six percent of decision-makers surveyed identify increasing active engagement as their top loyalty or membership priority over the next 24 months. A home insurer could offer maintenance discounts to create positive contact at renewal, then examine whether use is associated with stronger retention or interest in additional coverage, while accounting for customers’ prior engagement and renewal history. The benefit creates another engagement opportunity, but its commercial value depends on what that interaction contributes to the customer relationship over time.

A retailer might assess purchase frequency and spending alongside reward costs; a membership organization might examine renewal among members using new benefits. The economics will differ, but the underlying consideration is the same. Additional participation needs to generate enough value through spending, retention or other commercial outcomes to justify the cost of the rewards that encourage it.

Extending engagement beyond the core product

That potential gives organizations a commercial reason to consider benefits beyond their core products. A broader rewards portfolio can give members reasons to engage between purchases, policy renewals or other interactions with the organization. More than three-quarters of consumers surveyed would be interested if an organization they already buy from or belong to offered additional benefits through partnerships with other brands.

Partners can provide the rewards, redemption technology and servicing needed to extend the offering. Members gain access to savings and experiences they might otherwise seek elsewhere, making an existing relationship more useful in more areas of their lives.

That creates an opportunity for organizations to capture more of the spending and activity that would otherwise take place outside their loyalty programs. Whether members redeem more often, save rewards for a larger purchase, or use additional benefits between transactions, each represents a different form of participation with different commercial implications. A broader rewards portfolio ultimately earns its place when it gives members more reasons to participate and influences where they spend, what they redeem and whether they stay.

Discover which benefits members value, what encourages greater participation and where loyalty programs have opportunities to generate stronger commercial returns.

Download our latest loyalty research, Beyond Enrollment: The Wins, Losses and Opportunities in Loyalty.

Frequently asked questions

What types of loyalty rewards encourage members to participate?

In arrivia’s research, 40% of consumers said more valuable everyday rewards would increase their engagement, while 32% wanted bigger, more exciting rewards to work toward. Everyday savings give members a reason to use the program regularly, while larger rewards, such as travel, give them a goal to save for.

Why might members skip a reward they value?

Timing, availability and redemption requirements can all get in the way. A member may want to book a cruise, for example, but be unable to find a sailing that fits their schedule. Tracking where members stop during booking or redemption can help identify what’s keeping them from using the benefit.

How can businesses tell whether loyalty rewards are driving business results?

Compare redemption and repeat usage with outcomes such as member spending, purchase frequency and renewals. Account for members’ prior behavior and the cost of the rewards to assess whether increased participation generates enough additional value to justify the investment.

How can brand partnerships strengthen a loyalty program?

Partners can add benefits like travel savings that give members a reason to engage between purchases or renewals. In arrivia’s research, more than three-quarters of consumers said they’d be interested in additional benefits offered through brand partnerships by an organization they already buy from or belong to.